Case study 001 · US versions · editorial review

Apple's terms are a collection of layers.

A service contract, a cloud contract, a device license, and feature-specific AI notices can create different permissions and expectations. They must be examined separately.

What this study establishes

Documented

Permission ≠ practice

Several contracts reserve powers to limit access or monitor service use. A reserved power does not prove any particular user was monitored.

Documented

Different AI pathways

On-device/PCC operations, default Siri handling, optional model-improvement collection, and the ChatGPT extension have different privacy conditions.

Still open

Revocation after training

The deletion treatment of previously reviewed interactions and derived model contributions warrants a precise question—not a premature allegation.

Reading standard: Read publisher promises as publisher promises; read technical audits only within their stated scope; treat IBOR v1.5 as a disclosed proposed rights framework. We have not established any Apple legal violation.

Clause-level observations

The curated register below is a focused, source-linked publication sample. The accompanying research data contains a broader legacy 81-entry working inventory, marked as requiring further editorial verification. Neither is a sentence-by-sentence audit of every Apple legal document.

Showing 27 of 27 findings

F — Usage Rules

Publisher wording, paraphrased
Apple says it may monitor use of its Services and Content for compliance with usage rules.
Meaning and fair qualification
This wording describes a reserved permission, not evidence of broad inspection of device contents or continuous surveillance.
Unverified / not established
Scope of monitoring and technical means were not tested.
IBOR v1.5 comparison
IBOR I §1.4; VIII §8.1 — an ethical comparison, not a finding of legal breach.
Reader action
Read the usage rules before using automated tools.
Publisher source
Apple Media Services Terms and Conditions (US) · Source record

F — Usage Rules

Publisher wording, paraphrased
Apple restricts automated or equivalent manual scraping, copying, measurement, analysis, or monitoring of its defined Services or Content.
Meaning and fair qualification
The restriction is not automatically a ban on analyzing an individual’s own local documents; actual applicability depends on where information comes from and the activity.
Unverified / not established
No enforcement test or legal enforceability determination.
IBOR v1.5 comparison
IBOR XX §20.1 — an ethical comparison, not a finding of legal breach.
Reader action
Avoid collecting publisher content without assessing permitted access and applicable law.
Publisher source
Apple Media Services Terms and Conditions (US) · Source record

F — Usage Rules

Publisher wording, paraphrased
Apple restricts using Services, Content, or their outputs to train, fine-tune, or improve AI models or other software.
Meaning and fair qualification
The clause limits uses of covered material; it does not itself establish that Apple uses personal iCloud files to train AI.
Unverified / not established
Specific data, software, or exceptions may change applicability.
IBOR v1.5 comparison
IBOR II §2.1; XX §20.1 — an ethical comparison, not a finding of legal breach.
Reader action
For your own analysis, distinguish source terms, rights in content, and model-training rights.
Publisher source
Apple Media Services Terms and Conditions (US) · Source record

G — Termination

Publisher wording, paraphrased
Apple allows certain suspension or termination when it believes or suspects noncompliance, including some actions without notice.
Meaning and fair qualification
This provides a contractual remedy to Apple; consumer-law limits and actual enforcement require separate evidence.
Unverified / not established
No finding that a particular account was improperly suspended.
IBOR v1.5 comparison
IBOR VI §6.3 — an ethical comparison, not a finding of legal breach.
Reader action
Keep independent exports of your own purchases and records.
Publisher source
Apple Media Services Terms and Conditions (US) · Source record

I — Subscriptions

Publisher wording, paraphrased
Some subscriptions auto-renew until cancelled, and Apple describes notice and price-change consent under applicable conditions.
Meaning and fair qualification
Renewal is not the same as an unlimited right to charge; law, local terms, and cancellation timing matter.
Unverified / not established
Offer-specific price, receipt, and jurisdiction must be checked.
IBOR v1.5 comparison
IBOR II §2.1 — an ethical comparison, not a finding of legal breach.
Reader action
Review the specific renewal date and cancellation pathway.
Publisher source
Apple Media Services Terms and Conditions (US) · Source record

L — User submissions

Publisher wording, paraphrased
For certain public-facing submissions, Apple receives a worldwide, royalty-free, perpetual, nonexclusive license for stated purposes.
Meaning and fair qualification
The submission license is not a general transfer of ownership of all private files in iCloud.
Unverified / not established
Scope of each posted submission and governing law may vary.
IBOR v1.5 comparison
IBOR III §3.6 — an ethical comparison, not a finding of legal breach.
Reader action
Consider what you publish as a review, comment, or other service submission.
Publisher source
Apple Media Services Terms and Conditions (US) · Source record

T — Contract changes

Publisher wording, paraphrased
The agreement states modifications can take effect immediately and continued use is deemed acceptance.
Meaning and fair qualification
This is a contract-change mechanism; enforceability is not settled merely by the words used.
Unverified / not established
No historical version-by-version redline completed in this site prototype.
IBOR v1.5 comparison
IBOR II §2.1; §2.5 — an ethical comparison, not a finding of legal breach.
Reader action
Track version date and notice before concluding a term was newly imposed.
Publisher source
Apple Media Services Terms and Conditions (US) · Source record

Introduction — automatic enablement

Publisher wording, paraphrased
Apple describes iCloud activation during some device setups and automatic cloud storage when iCloud is enabled.
Meaning and fair qualification
This is conditional on configuration and feature choices, not a claim that every user enables every feature.
Unverified / not established
No on-device setting inspection.
IBOR v1.5 comparison
IBOR II §2.1; VIII §8.1 — an ethical comparison, not a finding of legal breach.
Reader action
Check iCloud settings and which apps synchronize content.
Publisher source
iCloud Terms and Conditions (US) · Source record

I.E — Changing the Service

Publisher wording, paraphrased
Apple generally promises 30 days’ advance notice of material adverse changes, subject to specific exceptions, with a qualified paid-service refund option.
Meaning and fair qualification
This is a genuine counterbalancing user protection; exceptions and whether a change is materially adverse matter.
Unverified / not established
No test of a particular notice or refund.
IBOR v1.5 comparison
IBOR II §2.5 — an ethical comparison, not a finding of legal breach.
Reader action
Keep copies of dated change notices.
Publisher source
iCloud Terms and Conditions (US) · Source record

II.G.6 — Apple Intelligence

Publisher wording, paraphrased
Apple lists Apple Intelligence among iCloud+ features and notes that certain features may have usage limits.
Meaning and fair qualification
An availability/limits clause is not itself permission to train a model on personal data.
Unverified / not established
Exact feature capabilities depend on device and region.
IBOR v1.5 comparison
IBOR I §1.4 — an ethical comparison, not a finding of legal breach.
Reader action
Read the distinct privacy notice for each AI data pathway.
Publisher source
iCloud Terms and Conditions (US) · Source record

II.J — Advanced Data Protection

Publisher wording, paraphrased
Advanced Data Protection is an opt-in feature that extends end-to-end encryption to additional data categories, with recovery responsibilities and exclusions.
Meaning and fair qualification
This is an important privacy-supportive mechanism; coverage is not universal and loss of recovery methods has consequences.
Unverified / not established
Technical implementation not independently audited in this project.
IBOR v1.5 comparison
IBOR VIII §8.1 — an ethical comparison, not a finding of legal breach.
Reader action
Review recovery options before enabling.
Publisher source
iCloud Terms and Conditions (US) · Source record

V.E — Access to Account and Content

Publisher wording, paraphrased
Apple describes circumstances in which it may access, preserve, use, disclose, screen, or remove account information/content, subject to the conditions stated.
Meaning and fair qualification
Contractual permission is distinct from technical access; encryption may prevent Apple reading particular protected content.
Unverified / not established
No verified record of access to a specific user account.
IBOR v1.5 comparison
IBOR III §3.1; VIII §8.1 — an ethical comparison, not a finding of legal breach.
Reader action
Compare the permission against encryption documentation and actual request records.
Publisher source
iCloud Terms and Conditions (US) · Source record

V.H — User content license

Publisher wording, paraphrased
Apple states it does not claim ownership of user-submitted iCloud content; publicly/shared content carries a limited service-purpose license.
Meaning and fair qualification
The license for public or shared content must not be conflated with the separate Media Services submissions license.
Unverified / not established
No audit of all third-party application data.
IBOR v1.5 comparison
IBOR III §3.6 — an ethical comparison, not a finding of legal breach.
Reader action
Preserve the distinction between private storage and shared postings.
Publisher source
iCloud Terms and Conditions (US) · Source record

VII — Termination

Publisher wording, paraphrased
Apple describes circumstances for suspension/termination and possible loss of access to cloud data afterward; certain notices and cure periods apply.
Meaning and fair qualification
Do not omit the 30-day cure provision for certain nonmaterial breaches.
Unverified / not established
How much time a user receives to export data in an individual case is unknown.
IBOR v1.5 comparison
IBOR III §3.1; XX §20.1 — an ethical comparison, not a finding of legal breach.
Reader action
Maintain independent copies of essential content.
Publisher source
iCloud Terms and Conditions (US) · Source record

Privacy notice — local/PCC

Publisher wording, paraphrased
Apple says many AI requests run on device and some more complex requests use Private Cloud Compute without retained request contents.
Meaning and fair qualification
This is a concrete privacy-design claim worthy of recognition, but the notice is not a complete independent runtime audit.
Unverified / not established
Per-request behavior not verified on the reader’s device.
IBOR v1.5 comparison
IBOR VIII §8.1 — an ethical comparison, not a finding of legal breach.
Reader action
Use the optional PCC report for visibility into some off-device requests.
Publisher source
Apple Intelligence & Privacy · Source record

Privacy notice — metadata

Publisher wording, paraphrased
Apple says it may collect limited size, feature, and duration metadata for PCC or Private Information Retrieval requests, without their content or account linkage.
Meaning and fair qualification
Even limited metadata should be distinguished from zero data collection.
Unverified / not established
Aggregate performance and unlinkability are publisher claims here.
IBOR v1.5 comparison
IBOR VIII §8.1; III §3.1 — an ethical comparison, not a finding of legal breach.
Reader action
Ask whether the data categories match the purpose and retention description.
Publisher source
Apple Intelligence & Privacy · Source record

Privacy notice — report

Publisher wording, paraphrased
Apple describes a locally enabled exportable Apple Intelligence & PCC Report covering certain off-device requests and supported extensions.
Meaning and fair qualification
The report can improve transparency but does not establish a complete log of every local inference or all processing.
Unverified / not established
Not tested with a device-generated report.
IBOR v1.5 comparison
IBOR I §1.4; XX §20.1 — an ethical comparison, not a finding of legal breach.
Reader action
Export the report and redact identifiers before sharing.
Publisher source
Apple Intelligence & Privacy · Source record

Siri and Dictation — optional opt-in

Publisher wording, paraphrased
Under the separate improvement program, Apple may retain audio, transcripts, responses, and related request data and use them to train foundation models.
Meaning and fair qualification
This program is distinct from ordinary on-device AI and cannot be assumed active for everyone.
Unverified / not established
No evidence this reader opted in or that any specific request was retained.
IBOR v1.5 comparison
IBOR II §§2.1, 2.3; III §3.3 — an ethical comparison, not a finding of legal breach.
Reader action
Check the separate Improve Siri & Apple Intelligence setting.
Publisher source
Improve Siri & Apple Intelligence & Privacy · Source record

Siri and Dictation — human review

Publisher wording, paraphrased
Apple says a subset of opted-in interactions may be reviewed by graders, with Siri audio review limited to Apple employees.
Meaning and fair qualification
Human review may be a quality-control mechanism while still creating privacy questions; it does not imply reviewers see all interactions.
Unverified / not established
Frequency of review and user-level instances not known.
IBOR v1.5 comparison
IBOR VIII §8.1; I §1.4 — an ethical comparison, not a finding of legal breach.
Reader action
Examine the disclosed classes of contextual data used by graders.
Publisher source
Improve Siri & Apple Intelligence & Privacy · Source record

Siri and Dictation — retention

Publisher wording, paraphrased
Apple describes up to two-year retention of opted-in data, with selected reviewed interactions potentially kept beyond two years.
Meaning and fair qualification
This duration is not evidence that Apple ignored a specific withdrawal; after-revocation processes are a separate question.
Unverified / not established
No tested deletion request or model-contribution remediation.
IBOR v1.5 comparison
IBOR II §2.3; III §3.3 — an ethical comparison, not a finding of legal breach.
Reader action
Keep a dated consent/revocation receipt and request the deletion scope in writing.
Publisher source
Improve Siri & Apple Intelligence & Privacy · Source record

General — third-party processing

Publisher wording, paraphrased
Apple says trusted third-party service providers may process and store information under the improvement program.
Meaning and fair qualification
The notice does not identify every subcontractor or prove their particular access for a given request.
Unverified / not established
Processor identities and controls not independently established here.
IBOR v1.5 comparison
IBOR II §2.1; VIII §8.1 — an ethical comparison, not a finding of legal breach.
Reader action
Seek processor categories and transfer details through published privacy channels.
Publisher source
Improve Siri & Apple Intelligence & Privacy · Source record

ChatGPT Extension section

Publisher wording, paraphrased
Apple says Siri-side requests and associated conversations using the extension may be retained under the optional improvement program.
Meaning and fair qualification
Apple-side retention and OpenAI-side handling are different processing arrangements.
Unverified / not established
No real extension request inspected.
IBOR v1.5 comparison
IBOR II §§2.1,2.3 — an ethical comparison, not a finding of legal breach.
Reader action
Review settings for both Improve Siri and the ChatGPT extension.
Publisher source
Improve Siri & Apple Intelligence & Privacy · Source record

With versus without account

Publisher wording, paraphrased
Apple describes separate pathways for using the extension signed out versus signed in, including different terms for OpenAI processing.
Meaning and fair qualification
The account state and relevant OpenAI settings matter; do not say one company’s policy automatically governs the other.
Unverified / not established
No account setting observed.
IBOR v1.5 comparison
IBOR II §2.1; III §3.1 — an ethical comparison, not a finding of legal breach.
Reader action
Confirm the extension account state and privacy choices.
Publisher source
ChatGPT Extension & Privacy · Source record

Default Siri and Dictation

Publisher wording, paraphrased
Apple describes some ordinary Siri usage and query data handling even without the optional improvement program.
Meaning and fair qualification
Turning off optional improvement sharing should not be described as eliminating all Siri service data processing.
Unverified / not established
No request-specific data trail provided.
IBOR v1.5 comparison
IBOR II §2.1; VIII §8.1 — an ethical comparison, not a finding of legal breach.
Reader action
Read the default Siri notice separately.
Publisher source
Siri, Dictation & Privacy · Source record

Improving Siri — deletion exception

Publisher wording, paraphrased
Apple says older-than-six-month and reviewed Siri requests may not be included in some server deletion because no longer linked to the random identifier.
Meaning and fair qualification
This is a substantive revocation question under IBOR; it is not by itself proof of unlawful conduct or an actual unfulfilled deletion request.
Unverified / not established
No individualized deletion request tested.
IBOR v1.5 comparison
IBOR II §2.3; III §3.3 — an ethical comparison, not a finding of legal breach.
Reader action
Ask Apple which retained categories can be located or deleted after withdrawal.
Publisher source
Apple Privacy — Features (Siri) · Source record

Usage Limits and Enforcement

Publisher wording, paraphrased
Apple reserves limits on excessive/automated use and may suspend access for violations; continued use after changes is treated as acceptance.
Meaning and fair qualification
Terms concern Apple Intelligence features, not every independent AI project running on a private machine.
Unverified / not established
No enforcement, technical, or legal applicability test for third-party workflows.
IBOR v1.5 comparison
IBOR I §1.4; XX §20.1 — an ethical comparison, not a finding of legal breach.
Reader action
Assess automated uses against these separate terms before scaling.
Publisher source
Apple Intelligence Usage Terms · Source record

Software license — scope

Publisher wording, paraphrased
The iOS 26 license describes Apple operating-system software as licensed, not sold, and includes jurisdiction-specific supplements.
Meaning and fair qualification
The referenced PDF has multiple languages and supplements; the exact version presented to a specific phone is not confirmed.
Unverified / not established
The 930-page multi-language PDF has not received line-by-line audit.
IBOR v1.5 comparison
IBOR I §1.4; XX §20.1 — an ethical comparison, not a finding of legal breach.
Reader action
Verify model, build, territory, and the displayed agreement version.
Publisher source
iOS 26 / iPadOS 26 Software License (multi-language PDF) · Source record

Consent: what can the reader control?

PathwayDisclosed controlImportant limit
Apple Intelligence off-deviceDevice privacy notice describes enabling PCC report exportReport is not an exhaustive log of all processing
Improve Siri & Apple IntelligenceSettings → Privacy & Security → Analytics & ImprovementsOpt-out does not necessarily delete historical records or derived models
ChatGPT extensionSettings → Apple Intelligence & Siri → ChatGPTApple-side and OpenAI-side data handling are different
iCloudiCloud settings, backups and encryption optionsAvailability, recovery, and storage choices vary

Menu labels can change by OS version; use Apple's current on-device help and verify what is present on your device.

IBOR v1.5 is a comparison framework, not Apple law

The published IBOR v1.5 text is a voluntary proposed framework. Especially relevant are Article II §§2.1 and 2.3 (specific consent and revocation), Article III §3.3 (deletion), Article VIII §8.1 (privacy by design), and Article XX (portability of rights records). Annex H addresses communicative dignity; it should not be misrepresented as a general data-deletion statute.

Apple's technical privacy safeguards can align with Article VIII. Extended retention and unspecified handling of model-derived information may raise unresolved normative tensions with Article II §2.3. This comparison does not demonstrate an enforceable violation.

Original source directory

These links open original publisher pages. We do not republish the complete agreements on this public sample. Version-date markers are not cryptographic attestations of the publisher's original bytes.

  1. Apple Media Services Terms and Conditions (US) — Contract; date: 2026-09-14. Official publisher source.
    Publisher page checked; text also supplied in conversation
  2. iCloud Terms and Conditions (US) — Contract; date: 2026-09-14. Official publisher source.
    Publisher page checked; text also supplied in conversation
  3. Apple Intelligence & Privacy — Privacy notice; date: 2026-09-14. Official publisher source.
    Publisher page checked; full notice supplied in conversation
  4. Improve Siri & Apple Intelligence & Privacy — Optional program privacy notice; date: 2026-10-26. Official publisher source.
    Publisher page checked; full notice supplied in conversation
  5. ChatGPT Extension & Privacy — Extension privacy notice; date: 2026-09-14. Official publisher source.
    Publisher page checked; account and non-account distinctions
  6. Siri, Dictation & Privacy — Core Siri privacy notice; date: Publisher date not verified here. Official publisher source.
    Publisher page checked; default data pathway
  7. Apple Privacy — Features (Siri) — Publisher explanation; date: Undated dynamic page. Official publisher source.
    Publisher page checked; transcript deletion caveat
  8. Apple Intelligence Usage Terms — Supplemental terms; date: 2026-09-09. Official publisher source.
    Publisher support page checked
  9. iOS 26 / iPadOS 26 Software License (multi-language PDF) — Operating-system license; date: English section original date requires version confirmation. Official publisher source.
    Publisher PDF first page visually checked; NOT fully audited (930 pages across languages)
  10. Apple Customer Privacy Policy — Umbrella privacy policy; date: Date not verified in this pass. Official publisher source.
    Landing page reachable, substantive text JavaScript-loaded; NOT independently fully audited
  11. AI and Intelligence Bill of Rights v1.5 — full text — Voluntary ethical framework; date: Version 1.5. Official publisher source.
    Full unabridged article/annex text accessible; voluntary framework, not Apple contractual undertaking

The operating-system PDF and Apple privacy-policy landing page are identified as partially reviewed; the iPhone-presented agreement and version are not independently authenticated in this prototype.