Public editorial standard · draft v0.1

Consent without comprehension is incomplete. Everyone deserves to know what they are agreeing to.

Our promise is comprehension supported by accountable evidence, not an accusation-driven scorecard.

Our five evidence compartments

  1. Publisher contract: identifiable legal agreement and exact clause/version.
  2. Publisher representation: product and privacy promises attributed to the publisher, without implying independent proof.
  3. Independent observation: published measurements or device tests whose scope and limits are stated.
  4. Editorial inference: an explanation or concern with qualifications and plausible alternate readings.
  5. Unknown: the evidence needed before a stronger conclusion is justified.

Before publication

Require a named version, country, and exact source; check quotations in context; identify counterbalancing safeguards; separate ethical norms from binding law; avoid motive claims or individual accusations; redact personal information; permit documented corrections. Findings about illegality, litigation, privacy incidents, data misuse, or regulatory compliance require qualified legal/subject-matter review.

Corrections and response

We welcome precise corrections with links or documents. A correction should be append-only with date, original statement, reason, revised text, and reviewer. Relevant companies should be offered a fair opportunity to identify factual errors before a high-consequence publication.

Limits

The site does not advise an individual to accept or reject a contract; it explains issues so that the reader can decide. A legal disclaimer does not immunize a publication from claims, and no publication process guarantees freedom from takedown requests.

See correction procedure and the included repository editorial and legal gate documents.